Old mailing instructions 

(English)

 

1. Your skipper name

2. Event, Seas., race # and time 3Nadeo given rule #

4. Skippers involved

5. Printscreen

6. Explainaition

7. Attached replay


Required info

 

Protest mail - 1-7

Cancel explanaition - 1-4, 6-7

 

To:

pc@swedenrace.se

Subject:

Division, Name, Mail type, Race

 

All mails must reach us before 20:00 (swedish time) the day after the race day!

 

We intend to reply, comfirming that a protest mail has

reached us.

 

 

 

VSR Racing Rules

 

These are the rules used in most VSK Fleet Race events organized by VSK Sweden Race (VSR).

Note that the rules are used in several events and do not include specifics about competition formats, schedules or maps.

The rules are presented initially in a summarized version and further down more in detail.

 

The VSR Racing Rules (VRR) are based upon ISAF Racing Rules of Sailing (ISAF RRS) with a few exceptions stated below.

 

Skippers may at any time protest against any other boat by writing: "P Skipper Name” in the game chat. The protesting skipper must fill out a Protest Form, (PF) after the races for the protest to be valid and examined.

 

The game setting used is "Fleet race - Complete (Auto)" which enables the in-game "umpire" to give penalties to the racing skippers. If a skipper disagrees with a given penalty, he may request an in-game penalty cancellation and the penalty giving skipper MUST accept this request. Otherwise he will be disqualified. If the penalty giving skipper thinks he has broken a rule, he may complete a penalty a.s.a.p. after the situation.

 

A skipper who requests a cancellation of a penalty MUST fill out a PF (explanation) after the races. Otherwise, he will be disqualified.

 

 

General

 

The host wil use the "Fleet race - Complete (Auto)" rule setting, but it will be possible to cancel penalties.

 

All valid protests, cancel request explanations and redress requests, will be examined by the Protest Committee (PC) after the races, using ISAF RRS. PC also has the right to review any other situation in a race where a rule might have been broken, regardless whether a PF is registered or not. If PC starts such a review, all skippers involved will be informed before any actions are taken.

 

NOTE that PC will look at ALL boats involved in a penalty situation, and may disqualify boats, regardless whether they have received an in-game penalty or not.

 

Except for a Rule 2 protest, the following applies:

A protest is not valid if the protested skipper accepts and completes the penalty a.s.a.p. after the incident. It is recommended that the skipper writes "360 done" in the chat after he has taken his penalty.

 

A PF must reach the PC before 20:00 CET (CEST) the day after the race day. Click on the button in the upper left hand corner of this page to fill out the form. If a skipper for some reason has trouble filling out the form, he may use the old mailing instructions below this button.

 

When protesting by writing "P Skipper Name" in the chat, the PF must include a Print Screen as evidence of protest.

 

An attached replay is always necessary completing the form.

 

A list including all protests and pen cancel requests received in time, will be posted in the VSR Forum after the protest time has expired.

 

A boat that has been protested in the chat, may give evidence by sending in a PF. This must be done within 24 hours after the protest is posted in the forum.

 

Nadeo uses an older version of the ISAF RRS addressing in-game penalties.

PC uses the ISAF RRS 2013-2016 with a few exceptions due to the fact that the races are held in a simulator. The most important ones are stated here:

- Part of the boat is only hull and mast

- No general recall due to false starts

- The mark zone is 2 hull lengths

- All penalties include 1 tack and one gybe

- A skipper must complete a penalty a.s.a.p. after situation (Within 60 sec. after Nadeo given penalties)

- Skippers need to hail P “Skipper Name” in the game chat in order to protest

- Skippers need to hail “RTT” or "Room to tack" in the game chat in order to use rule 20

 

The host is allowed to restart any prestart before 1 min to start.

 

 

Cancellations

 

Racing skippers may request a cancellation for a penalty they think are wrong as soon as possible after an incident.

(>30 seconds after an incident is considered late).

 

All cancellation requests MUST be accepted. A boat refusing, not answering or answering late to a cancellation request, regardless whether by intent or by mistake, will be disqualified. He may also be kicked from the course by the host, if he doesn't leave.

(>20 seconds after a request is considered late).

 

A boat making a cancellation request must fill out a PF (explanation) available in the upper left hand corner of this page. If no PF is received, the skipper will be disqualified and the PC will not examine the situation further.

(This does not apply for rule 17.1).

The penalty giving boat may take a penalty if he thinks he has broken any rule in the situation.

The requesting boat cannot change his mind and complete a penalty turn afterwards.

PC may need to contact parties involved, to gather more information for making a correct decision.

 

Compensation/Redress

If a PF asking for redress is received, or if PC itself finds that a rule has been broken, a redress may be given in these situations:

- If a Pen Cancel Request is refused, not answered or answered too late

- If a boat is badly affected by another boat's "ghost". I.e. a boat which has already disconnected

- If a boat's result is affected by another boat breaking Rule 2

 

A redress will only affect the score of the compensated skipper and this score may be calculated in different ways using ISAF RRS.

 

 

Rule 2 Protest

 

At any time during a race, a boat/team can protest another boat/team in the chat under Rule 2. This changes ISAF RRS 61.1(a), since the call does not have to be right after the incident.

 

PC may also protest any boat/team under Rule 2, if it hears, learns or sees an infringement that may be a violation of Rule 2. PC will then inform the boat/team a.s.a.p. and the protested boat/team may give evidence. The evidence shall be sent within 24 hours after the protest is posted in the forum.

 

ISAF RRS:

"...

BASIC PRINCIPLE

SPORTMANSHIP AND THE RULES

Competitors in the sport of sailing are governed by a body of rules that they are expected to follow and enforce. A fundamental principle of sportmanship is that when competitors break a rule they will promptly take a penalty, which may be to retire.

...

RULE 2

FAIR SAILING

A boat and her owner shall compete in compliance with recognized principles of sportmanship and fair play. A boat may be penalized under this rule if it is clearly established that these principles have been violated. A disqualification under this rule shall not be excluded from the boat's series score.

..."

 

This rule regulates fair, honest and sportive sailing, which can basically be divided into 3 parts:

- You should not deliberately break a rule.

- If you know you have broken a rule (or should have known...), then you should voluntarily take a penalty.

- Choose your words carefully when using the chat. Foul language is not accepted. Insults directed at a particular skipper are shown to everybody in the race...

 

So if you have deliberately broken a rule, not volunteered to take a penalty when you clearly should have, or have abused the race chat, then you may have broken Rule 2.

 

 

Protest decisions

 

The protest decisions will be published in the VSK Forum when PC has evaluated all situations. Click the "Protest Decisions" button in the upper right hand corner to get you there.

 

The PC decisions are final and cannot be appealed.

 



Protest Committee

Jury:

Ivanhoe

Spirillen

Tribordais

YoKKo

 

Admin:

Div 1: Winslow

Div 2: Goffe



Would you like to be a part of the protest committee?

 

Apply to: pc@swedenrace.se

Subject: PC application

(TS3 and english required)